CBCA 1747, 1748, 1749, 1750, 2157

Higgins Development Partners, LLP

Oct 8, 2010Judge SomersDEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES
Not published in the listingGranted in partby agreement

Key Facts

Appellant
Higgins Development Partners, LLP
Respondent agency
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES
Judge
Somers
Case number
CBCA 1747, 1748, 1749, 1750, 2157This cell names 5 dockets: 1747, 1748, 1749, 1750, 2157.
Decided
Oct 8, 2010The decision states Oct 8, 2010 on its own face, which agrees with the listing.
Decision type
Not published in the listingThe Board's year tables for 2007 through 2014 carry no Type column, so no disposition was published for this decision. It is not missing data and nothing is inferred from the document.
Law firm for the appellant
The decision's own appearances block names no outside firm, which happens when the appellant appeared pro se, through one of its own officers, or through its in-house counsel.
Outcome
Granted in partEntered by agreement of the parties.
The appeals are GRANTED IN PART in the amount of $8,550,000, inclusive of all interest and costs, to be paid in accordance with 31 U.S.C. § 1304.
Read from the shouted disposition line the Board prints above this decision's own date, and quoted from its operative sentence above. No model is involved.

Topics

The topic rules ran over this decision's own words and none of them matched.

Topics are derived from each decision's own text by keyword rules, not a classification by the Board. A decision matching several topics carries all of them, so topic counts sum above the number of decisions.

Appearances

For the appellant
Thomas Finnerty
Higgins Development Partners, LLP
Chicago, IL
For the appellant
John P. Ahlers and Scott R. Sleight
Ahlers & Cressman, PLLC, Seattle
For the respondent
Richard G. Bergeron
Office of the General Counsel, Department of Health and Human Services
Washington, DC
Decision PDF (cbca.gov) Civilian Board of Contract Appeals, Contract Disputes Act casesThe Board's year listing this row was read fromThe decision document is hosted by the Board itself, so it is an official copy, and the Board's own Contract Disputes Act case listing is the citable source. The topics, the disposition and the appearances above are read deterministically from the decision's own words; no model is involved.

Research This Decision

Create a free account to open this decision in the CBCA workspace: a grounded decision brief drafted from the Board's own words, the Insights dashboard over the whole corpus, and the filtered browser.

CBCA Decision Brief

A Workflows Hub brief on this decision, drafted from the captured text with every quote and authority checked against it.

Insights

Who prevails before the Board, by topic and by judge, with every denominator visible: merits rulings, not decisions.

Browse with Filters

The whole corpus by year, decision type, topic, judge and disposition, searchable across the decisions' own text.

Full Decision

Full text of the decision2 pages, 2,634 characters, read from the Board's own documentDecided Oct 8, 2010 on its own faceRespondent DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES Decision documentOfficial source: Civilian Board of Contract Appeals, Contract Disputes Act cases

Authorities cited

1 authority read from this decision's own text, grouped by the body of law each comes from. Select one to read it at its publisher.

Other statutes1

Read from the decision's own words with no model involved. Statutes, regulations, the acts these forums argue by name, and cases at the board, this office or the Comptroller General are recognized; any other citation form is left out rather than guessed at, so this is a floor on what the decision cites.

GRANTED IN PART: October 8, 2010

CBCA 1747, 1748, 1749, 1750, 2157

HIGGINS DEVELOPMENT PARTNERS, LLP,

Appellant,

v.

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES,

Respondent.

The case caption as the decision prints it. Every word is kept; the rule the Board draws around it is not text, so it is not repeated here.

Thomas Finnerty, Senior Vice President of Higgins Development Partners, LLP, Chicago, IL, appearing for Appellant; and John P. Ahlers and Scott R. Sleight of Ahlers & Cressman, PLLC, Seattle, WA, appearing for Skanska USA Building Inc.

Richard G. Bergeron, Office of the General Counsel, Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, DC, counsel for Respondent.

Before Board Judges SOMERS, HYATT, and POLLACK.

SOMERS, Board Judge.

On October 6, 2009, appellant, Higgins Development Partners, filed four appeals in connection with Department of Health and Human Services contract number 292-02-C-0326, for the development and construction of a National Institutes of Health integrated research facility.

On September 2, 2010, the parties filed a joint motion for entry of decision by stipulation, stating that the parties had reached a global settlement of all claims arising out of the contract. On September 23, 2010, appellant filed an appeal of the claims resolved in ____________________________

___________________________ ____________________________ the settlement that had not been filed with the Board. On September 28, 2010, all five appeals were consolidated. The joint motion stated, in part: The parties have reached a global settlement resolving all 85 claims arising out of the development and construction contract . . . ; By executing their Settlement Agreement and filing this Motion, the parties hereby stipulate to a Decision by the Board awarding eight million five-hundred fifty thousand dollars and no cents ($8,550,000.00) to Appellant Higgins Development Partners, LLC and Skanska USA Building, Inc., as joint payees; and

2CBCA 1747, 1748, 1749, 1750, 2157

The parties further stipulate as follows: (a) they will not seek reconsideration of, or relief from, the Board’s decision; (b) they will not appeal the decision; and (c) they understand that the Board’s decision pursuant to this joint motion is an adjudication of the case on the merits.

Decision

Pursuant to the agreement of the parties and Rule 25(b), the Board adopts the parties’ joint motion for entry of decision by stipulation, and in accordance with the parties’ settlement agreement, the Board enters judgment as requested. The appeals are GRANTED IN PART in the amount of $8,550,000, inclusive of all interest and costs, to be paid in accordance with 31 U.S.C. § 1304.

JERI KAYLENE SOMERS

Board Judge

We concur:

CATHERINE B. HYATT

Board Judge

HOWARD A. POLLACK

Board Judge

This is a verbatim capture of the text layer of the Board's own document in Higgins Development Partners, LLP, CBCA 1747, 1748, 1749, 1750, 2157. Nothing is summarized or reworded, and the sections run in the order the Board wrote them. What the page shows and the text does not repeat is the pagination furniture: the page numbers and the rules the Board draws around its caption and under its signatures. The signatures are set back into the columns the Board prints them in, each judge under the name he or she signed, and the typed copy of that name the page carries beneath each signature is not repeated.

Related Decisions

Same Judge

Newsletter

New decisions every Monday

GovConDash Weekly lists the decisions GAO, the boards, the courts and SBA OHA released that week, alongside the FAR Overhaul deviations and proposed rules that reach every contractor. Free.

Free, weekly, and one click to unsubscribe. We send a confirmation email first. See our Privacy Policy.