CBCA 3286, 3517, 3573, 3574, 3575

Mascaro Construction Company, L.P.

Mar 10, 2016Judge SheridanGENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION
DecisionGranted in partby agreement

Key Facts

Appellant
Mascaro Construction Company, L.P.
Respondent agency
GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION
Judge
Sheridan
Case number
CBCA 3286, 3517, 3573, 3574, 3575This cell names 5 dockets: 3286, 3517, 3573, 3574, 3575.
Decided
Mar 10, 2016The decision states Mar 10, 2016 on its own face, which agrees with the listing.
Decision type
Decision
Law firm for the appellant
Blumling & Gusky, LLP, Duke, Holzman, Photiadis & Gresens, LLP, Sheats & Bailey, PLLC, Wiley Rein LLP
Outcome
Granted in partEntered by agreement of the parties.
Accordingly, these appeals are GRANTED IN PART.
Read from the shouted disposition line the Board prints above this decision's own date, and quoted from its operative sentence above. No model is involved.

Topics

The topic rules ran over this decision's own words and none of them matched.

Topics are derived from each decision's own text by keyword rules, not a classification by the Board. A decision matching several topics carries all of them, so topic counts sum above the number of decisions.

Appearances

For the appellant
Michael D. Klein and Ross A. Giorgianni
Blumling & Gusky, LLP
Pittsburgh, PA
For the appellant
Edward J. Sheats
Sheats & Bailey, PLLC
Brewerton, NY
For the appellant
Gregory P. Photiadis and Ryan L. Belka
Duke, Holzman, Photiadis & Gresens, LLP
Buffalo, NY
For the appellant
Christopher M. Mills
Wiley Rein LLP
Washington, DC
For the respondent
Lori R. Shapiro and Justin Hawkins
Office of General Counsel, General Services Administration
Washington, DC
Decision PDF (cbca.gov) Civilian Board of Contract Appeals, Contract Disputes Act casesThe Board's year listing this row was read fromThe decision document is hosted by the Board itself, so it is an official copy, and the Board's own Contract Disputes Act case listing is the citable source. The topics, the disposition and the appearances above are read deterministically from the decision's own words; no model is involved.

Research This Decision

Create a free account to open this decision in the CBCA workspace: a grounded decision brief drafted from the Board's own words, the Insights dashboard over the whole corpus, and the filtered browser.

CBCA Decision Brief

A Workflows Hub brief on this decision, drafted from the captured text with every quote and authority checked against it.

Insights

Who prevails before the Board, by topic and by judge, with every denominator visible: merits rulings, not decisions.

Browse with Filters

The whole corpus by year, decision type, topic, judge and disposition, searchable across the decisions' own text.

Full Decision

Full text of the decision2 pages, 2,637 characters, read from the Board's own documentDecided Mar 10, 2016 on its own faceRespondent GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION Decision documentOfficial source: Civilian Board of Contract Appeals, Contract Disputes Act cases

Authorities cited

1 authority read from this decision's own text, grouped by the body of law each comes from. Select one to read it at its publisher.

Other statutes1

Read from the decision's own words with no model involved. Statutes, regulations, the acts these forums argue by name, and cases at the board, this office or the Comptroller General are recognized; any other citation form is left out rather than guessed at, so this is a floor on what the decision cites.

GRANTED IN PART: March 10, 2016

CBCA 3286, 3517, 3573, 3574, 3575

MASCARO CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, L.P.,

Appellant,

v.

GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION,

Respondent.

The case caption as the decision prints it. Every word is kept; the rule the Board draws around it is not text, so it is not repeated here.

Michael D. Klein and Ross A. Giorgianni of Blumling & Gusky, LLP, Pittsburgh, PA; Edward J. Sheats of Sheats & Bailey, PLLC, Brewerton, NY; Gregory P. Photiadis and Ryan L. Belka of Duke, Holzman, Photiadis & Gresens, LLP, Buffalo, NY; and Christopher M. Mills of Wiley Rein LLP, Washington, DC, counsel for Appellant.

Lori R. Shapiro and Justin Hawkins, Office of General Counsel, General Services Administration, Washington, DC, counsel for Respondent.

Before Board Judges SHERIDAN, ZISCHKAU, and SULLIVAN.

SHERIDAN, Board Judge.

In these appeals, appellant, Mascaro Construction Company, L.P., appealed decisions of a contracting officer of respondent, General Services Administration (GSA), arising from its contract for construction of the Federal courthouse in Buffalo, New York. On February 8, 2016, the parties filed a joint motion for stipulated award for the Board to enter a full and final judgment, stating in part that: 7. The parties desired to settle the Claims, Appeals, and any [sic] fully and finally resolve any claims that Mascaro and/or its Subcontractors had or may have had, so the parties entered into the Settlement Agreement.

8. Under the Settlement Agreement, Mascaro shall accept on behalf of itself and its subcontractors, the total sum of $11,000,000.00 (“Settlement Amount”) in full and final settlement of all matters relating to the Contract, including without limitation the Claims and Appeals. To effect payment of the Settlement Amount, the parties agreed to enter into a joint stipulation in which the parties request that the Board enter final judgment in the total sum of $11,000,000.00. The Settlement Amount is inclusive of any costs, interest, and attorney fees claimed or unclaimed, by Mascaro on behalf of itself and its Subcontractors.

9. Payment of the final judgment amount, that is $11,000,000.00, is to be made from the permanent indefinite judgment fund. 31 U.S.C. § 1304 (2008).

10. Pursuant to Rule 25(b) of the Board’s Rules of Procedure, the parties state that neither party will seek reconsideration of, or relief from, the Board’s decision, and they will not appeal the decision.

Decision

Accordingly, these appeals are GRANTED IN PART. In accordance with the parties’ motion, the Board awards the total sum of $11,000,000 to be paid from the judgment fund. This amount is inclusive of all costs, interest, and attorney fees.

PATRICIA J. SHERIDAN

Board Judge

We concur:

JONATHAN D. ZISCHKAU

Board Judge

MARIAN E. SULLIVAN

Board Judge

This is a verbatim capture of the text layer of the Board's own document in Mascaro Construction Company, L.P., CBCA 3286, 3517, 3573, 3574, 3575. Nothing is summarized or reworded, and the sections run in the order the Board wrote them. What the page shows and the text does not repeat is the pagination furniture: the page numbers and the rules the Board draws around its caption and under its signatures. The signatures are set back into the columns the Board prints them in, each judge under the name he or she signed, and the typed copy of that name the page carries beneath each signature is not repeated.

Related Decisions

Same Judge

Same Year

Newsletter

New decisions every Monday

GovConDash Weekly lists the decisions GAO, the boards, the courts and SBA OHA released that week, alongside the FAR Overhaul deviations and proposed rules that reach every contractor. Free.

Free, weekly, and one click to unsubscribe. We send a confirmation email first. See our Privacy Policy.