59655

Islands Mechanical Contractor, Inc.

April 13, 2017Judge Sweet
DismissedDiffering Site ConditionsCDA Jurisdiction

Islands Mechanical Contractor, Inc. appealed a deemed denial of its claim under a firm-fixed-price contract for wastewater treatment system repairs. The Board dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction due to failure to certify a claim for a sum certain.

Material Facts

  • In 2006, the Department of the Navy awarded IMC Contract No. N69272-06-C-0012, a firm-fixed-price contract to provide wastewater treatment system repairs at Naval Station Guantanamo Bay.
  • IMC began performance in 2006.
  • IMC alleges that it encountered differing and unforeseen site conditions and that NAVFAC provided defective plans and specifications.
  • IMC alleges that it submitted requests for information (RFIs) to NAVFAC seeking guidance regarding how to proceed, but NAVFAC did not respond to all RFIs.
  • On 3 April 2009, IMC placed all of its equipment on stand-by status due to the lack of response from NAVFAC.
  • IMC alleges that the failure to respond to the RFIs caused delay and damages.
  • IMC submitted a proposal to complete contract 0012 for $373,121.72, which NAVFAC has not accepted.
  • On 29 July 2014, IMC resubmitted a request for equitable adjustment as a certified claim, seeking $2,151,801.86 in direct labor and equipment costs and $2,308,966.96 in indirect overhead costs.
  • The second revised claim sought $1,494,996.09 in stand-by equipment costs and $479,382.79 in home office overhead costs.
  • The appeal was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction because IMC's claims did not meet the sum certain requirement.

Parties

Appellant
Islands Mechanical Contractor, Inc.
Respondent Agency
Department of the Navy
Contract Number
N69272-06-C-0012
Open Official Decision PDF (asbca.mil)AI-analyzed, grounded in the decision text. Verify against the official PDF before relying on it.

Full Legal Analysis

Create a free account to read the complete grounded legal brief for this decision, including the holding, every issue the Board decided, quantum, verified citations, and the case's citation graph.

Holding & Legal Reasoning

The Board's holding, background, and procedural posture for this decision.

Issues Presented

Every issue the Board decided, with its determination, reasoning, and supporting authority.

Quantum & Recovery

The claimed, awarded, and net dollar amounts at issue, itemized where the record supports it.

Verified Authorities & Citations

Every cited FAR, DFARS, CAS, and case-law authority, cross-checked against the source text.

Practitioner Takeaways

Practical guidance for contractors and counsel, distilled from the Board's ruling.

Similar Cases

Related decisions surfaced by semantic search across the full analyzed corpus.

Citation Graph

An interactive graph of this case's cited authorities, judge, agency, and related decisions.

Related Decisions

Same Judge

Same Year

Same Issue

Newsletter

New decisions every Monday

GovConDash Weekly lists the decisions GAO, the boards, the courts and SBA OHA released that week, alongside the FAR Overhaul deviations and proposed rules that reach every contractor. Free.

Free, weekly, and one click to unsubscribe. We send a confirmation email first. See our Privacy Policy.